Best Amazon FBA Alternatives
On January 1, 2026, Amazon discontinued FBA prep and labeling services in the US. In May 2025, the platform cut capacity calculations from six months to five months of projected sales. The IPI threshold to avoid storage limits rose from 500 to 550. Aged-inventory fees on 12-to-15-month-old units doubled to $0.30 per unit per month. Low-inventory-level fees now require 35 days of stock to dodge a per-unit penalty, up from 28 days a year ago. None of these are line items a seller can model away — they are structural shifts in what FBA costs and how it constrains an inventory plan.
Read Amazon FBA review →Start with the fit that matches the switch
Scan the shortlist quickly by use case, then jump straight to the provider below that looks closest to the way the operation actually needs to run.
Best for multichannel DTC at scale
Best for heavy, fragile, high-value goods
Best for kitting, subscription, and TikTok Shop
Best for apparel-focused mid-market DTC
Best for mid-market omnichannel + B2B
Best for software-first DTC + B2B hybrid
Best for SMB pay-as-you-go (no minimums)
Best for import-heavy Shopify brands
Best for flat-rate pricing with human account managers
What to prioritize in a replacement
- 1State the operational reason for leaving before opening demos.
- 2Shortlist providers built for the catalog and channel mix you will have next year.
- 3Use direct comparison pages only after the field is down to one or two viable fits.
Four orthogonal questions narrow the field fast. Answer them in order.
1. What's your weight profile?
Average shipment under 1 lb routes naturally to ShipBob, ShipMonk, or Flexport — all built around fast-shipping DTC economics. Shipments between 1 and 5 lb favor ShipBob, LVK, or Saddle Creek, where mid-weight DTC is the core profile. Anything over 5 lb, fragile, or high-value should go to Red Stag — their accuracy guarantee and damage handling specifically target goods that lose money on every mispick.
2. How many sales channels?
Amazon plus Shopify only: ShipBob, ShipMonk, or LVK handle both natively with no middleware — LVK is the apparel-leaning pick. Multi-marketplace including Walmart, eBay, and TikTok Shop: ShipMonk or ShipBob have the deepest native integrations — ShipBob also covers Temu and SHEIN. Heavy B2B alongside DTC: Stord or Saddle Creek, where EDI capability and retail compliance are first-class rather than bolt-ons. Note: TikTok reversed its mandatory-logistics policy in February 2026, so 3PL fulfillment of TikTok Shop orders is permitted again.
3. What's your daily order volume?
Under 50 orders per day: eFulfillment Service or a regional 3PL — large software-first 3PLs charge minimums that do not pencil at this volume, and eFS is the only national lineup option built around pay-as-you-go billing. 50 to 500 per day: ShipBob, ShipMonk, LVK, or Red Stag — the sweet spot for mid-market 3PLs. 500 to 2,000 per day: Saddle Creek or Stord — enterprise-grade ops without an SAP-tier WMS project. Over 2,000 per day: custom enterprise vendors outside this lineup.
4. Leaving FBA entirely or de-risking?
Full exit: a single 3PL fulfilling Amazon FBM listings alongside DTC. Most brands take 4 to 8 weeks to migrate inventory out of FBA — plan for the lag. De-risking only: hybrid setup with high-velocity SKUs staying on FBA and slower-moving inventory at a 3PL. Want to keep the Prime badge while leaving FBA's warehouses: an SFP-certified 3PL — Red Stag or ShipMonk in this lineup.
Options worth a closer look
Use the chooser above as the fast path by use case. The cards below add the operational context, supporting detail, and next links once the shortlist is down to the most plausible fits.
ShipBob
60+ fulfillment centers across five countries with native Shopify, Amazon, TikTok Shop, Walmart, Temu, and SHEIN integration — the broadest channel reach in the lineup.
- Best for
- Growth-stage DTC brands on Shopify shipping 500–50,000 orders per month across multiple channels.
- Edge
- Largest hybrid owned-and-partner US network with the deepest native marketplace integrations.
ShipBob
60+ fulfillment centers across five countries with native Shopify, Amazon, TikTok Shop, Walmart, Temu, and SHEIN integration — the broadest channel reach in the lineup.
ShipBob runs 60+ fulfillment centers across five countries through a hybrid model — company-owned Innovation Centers paired with a 40+ partner 3PL network, all on ShipBob's WMS. The Shopify-first software experience is the strongest in the category, and native integrations cover Amazon, TikTok Shop, Walmart, eBay, Temu, and SHEIN with no middleware. Pricing is custom-quote and runs at the higher end for the size bracket; merchants on Reddit consistently report 'great software, fees creep up.' Not a fit if you are sub-50 orders/day (the platform is not cost-justified at low volume), if you ship oversized or regulated SKUs, or if you specifically need Seller Fulfilled Prime — ShipBob handles FBA prep instead of operating SFP-certified warehouses. For mid-market multichannel DTC, ShipBob is the default starting point.
- Best for
- Growth-stage DTC brands on Shopify shipping 500–50,000 orders per month across multiple channels.
- Operational edge
- Largest hybrid owned-and-partner US network with the deepest native marketplace integrations.
Red Stag Fulfillment
Two-warehouse US footprint with a 100% order accuracy guarantee and SFP capability — the right fit for products where mispicks and damage destroy unit economics.
- Best for
- Brands shipping items over 5 lb, fragile, or high-value where accuracy and damage avoidance drive economics.
- Edge
- Founder-owned 3PL with a 100% accuracy SLA, $50 compensation per error, and explicit Seller Fulfilled Prime support.
Red Stag Fulfillment
Two-warehouse US footprint with a 100% order accuracy guarantee and SFP capability — the right fit for products where mispicks and damage destroy unit economics.
Red Stag operates two strategic US warehouses — Sweetwater, TN and Salt Lake City, UT — reaching 96% of the country within two days via ground shipping. The differentiator is the SLA: 100% accuracy guarantee with $50 per error compensation, plus paid penalties for missed pickup or shipping deadlines. The team is small enough that account management is a real human, not a queue. Red Stag is one of two SFP-capable 3PLs in this lineup, which makes it the right call for brands that need to keep their Prime badge while leaving FBA's warehouses. Not a fit for apparel, footwear, or commodity DTC where accuracy is not worth a premium — the per-order pricing will not beat ShipBob or ShipMonk on small-and-light SKUs. For heavy-and-bulky, supplements, or any product where a 0.5% error rate already costs real money, Red Stag is where the math works.
- Best for
- Brands shipping items over 5 lb, fragile, or high-value where accuracy and damage avoidance drive economics.
- Operational edge
- Founder-owned 3PL with a 100% accuracy SLA, $50 compensation per error, and explicit Seller Fulfilled Prime support.
ShipMonk
12 owned-and-operated facilities across the US, Canada, UK, and Czech Republic with native kitting workflows, SFP support, and TikTok Shop integration.
- Best for
- Growth-stage DTC, subscription, and crowdfunding brands needing multi-node reach with international capability.
- Edge
- Proprietary OMS/WMS platform with deep subscription-box and kitting capability, plus international owned facilities and SFP support.
ShipMonk
12 owned-and-operated facilities across the US, Canada, UK, and Czech Republic with native kitting workflows, SFP support, and TikTok Shop integration.
ShipMonk operates 12 owned fulfillment centers across the US, Canada, UK, and Czech Republic, every facility on its proprietary OMS/WMS. The differentiator is depth in non-standard workflows — kitting, subscription-box assembly, crowdfunding-campaign fulfillment, apparel returns — handled inside the platform rather than as add-on services. ShipMonk explicitly supports Seller Fulfilled Prime with a published 99.99% accuracy rate. TikTok Shop, Kickstarter, Indiegogo, and Walmart are all native integrations. Pricing is custom-quote and skews mid-market to enterprise. Not a fit for very low-volume brands or operators wanting simple flat-rate pricing — the platform's complexity is wasted at low scale. For DTC brands with kitting volume, subscription cadence, or international DTC alongside Amazon, ShipMonk's specialty workflows save real ops time.
- Best for
- Growth-stage DTC, subscription, and crowdfunding brands needing multi-node reach with international capability.
- Operational edge
- Proprietary OMS/WMS platform with deep subscription-box and kitting capability, plus international owned facilities and SFP support.
LVK Logistics
Seven owned-and-operated fulfillment centers across the US and Canada built on ShipHero WMS — the apparel-focused mid-market spinoff from ShipHero's 2024 fulfillment carve-out.
- Best for
- Mid-market DTC apparel and CPG brands on Shopify shipping 500+ orders per month who want hands-on account management and ShipHero-grade tech.
- Edge
- ShipHero-grade technology paired with hands-on account teams, operationally analogous to ShipHero's former fulfillment business and led by its former COO.
LVK Logistics
Seven owned-and-operated fulfillment centers across the US and Canada built on ShipHero WMS — the apparel-focused mid-market spinoff from ShipHero's 2024 fulfillment carve-out.
LVK Logistics is the fulfillment company spun off from ShipHero in August 2024 — same WMS, same playbook, now operating as a standalone apparel-focused 3PL under CEO Maggie Barnett, the former ShipHero COO. Seven owned-and-operated fulfillment centers across Pennsylvania, Texas, Florida, Nevada, Utah, and Canada give LVK national US coverage plus a Canadian node. Built on ShipHero WMS, LVK pairs that tech depth with hands-on account teams aimed at brands that have outgrown commodity 3PLs but do not want enterprise-contract weight. Native integrations cover Shopify, Amazon, and WooCommerce. Pricing is custom-quote. Not a fit for sub-500-order brands, sellers needing EU/UK/APAC fulfillment, or merchants who require fully published transparent pricing. For mid-market apparel and DTC brands on Shopify shipping 500-plus orders per month wanting ShipHero-quality tech without operating their own warehouse, LVK is the cleanest answer in the lineup.
- Best for
- Mid-market DTC apparel and CPG brands on Shopify shipping 500+ orders per month who want hands-on account management and ShipHero-grade tech.
- Operational edge
- ShipHero-grade technology paired with hands-on account teams, operationally analogous to ShipHero's former fulfillment business and led by its former COO.
Saddle Creek Logistics
46 facilities and 31 million square feet of US warehouse space bundling DTC fulfillment, B2B retail distribution, contract packaging, and transportation under a single vendor.
- Best for
- Mid-market DTC and retail brands with 5,000+ monthly orders wanting omnichannel and B2B under one roof.
- Edge
- Asset-based 3PL controlling its own warehouses and trucking, with end-to-end services from container to retail shelf to consumer doorstep.
Saddle Creek Logistics
46 facilities and 31 million square feet of US warehouse space bundling DTC fulfillment, B2B retail distribution, contract packaging, and transportation under a single vendor.
Saddle Creek runs 46 facilities and 31 million square feet of US warehouse space from its Lakeland, FL headquarters — one of the largest privately-held 3PL footprints in the country. The model is asset-based: Saddle Creek owns the warehouses and operates its own trucking, which gives it cost-stack control most software-first 3PLs do not have. The bundle is the value proposition: omnichannel DTC fulfillment, B2B retail distribution with EDI compliance, transportation brokerage, and contract packaging all from a single contract. Native integrations include Shopify, Amazon, NetSuite, and EDI. Pricing is custom-quote and oriented toward enterprise. Not a fit for early-stage startups, sub-1K orders/month, or US-only brands needing international fulfillment. For mid-market brands hitting the ceiling of software-first 3PLs and needing asset-based depth, Saddle Creek is the next stop.
- Best for
- Mid-market DTC and retail brands with 5,000+ monthly orders wanting omnichannel and B2B under one roof.
- Operational edge
- Asset-based 3PL controlling its own warehouses and trucking, with end-to-end services from container to retail shelf to consumer doorstep.
Stord
Stord One software platform — proprietary WMS, OMS, and TMS — paired with owned warehouses and a 1,000+ node partner network for high-volume omnichannel brands.
- Best for
- High-volume omnichannel brands needing integrated fulfillment software and supply chain visibility.
- Edge
- End-to-end supply-chain software (WMS + OMS + TMS) plus a 1,000+ node fulfillment network — the deepest tech stack in the lineup.
Stord
Stord One software platform — proprietary WMS, OMS, and TMS — paired with owned warehouses and a 1,000+ node partner network for high-volume omnichannel brands.
Stord pairs its own software stack — Stord One, covering WMS, OMS, and TMS — with company-owned warehouses and a 1,000+ node partner network. The result is a single visibility layer across fulfillment, transportation, and inventory that most 3PLs cannot match. Specialties span DTC, B2B, omnichannel, cold-chain, food and beverage, health and wellness, supplements, apparel, and CPG. Integration depth is API-first with native Shopify and ERP support. Pricing typically runs around $30,000 per year platform fee plus per-order and storage charges — custom-quote and oriented toward mid-market to enterprise. Not a fit for low-volume startups or brands wanting simple per-order pricing — the platform fee makes the math work above mid-thousands of orders monthly. For brands wanting their fulfillment vendor to also be their supply-chain visibility tool, Stord is the clearest answer.
- Best for
- High-volume omnichannel brands needing integrated fulfillment software and supply chain visibility.
- Operational edge
- End-to-end supply-chain software (WMS + OMS + TMS) plus a 1,000+ node fulfillment network — the deepest tech stack in the lineup.
eFulfillment Service
Per-order billing since 2001 with no setup fees, monthly minimums, or long-term contracts — the lineup's only true SMB-friendly transactional 3PL.
- Best for
- SMB DTC and marketplace sellers under roughly 1,000 orders per month who want per-order billing and dedicated account support.
- Edge
- Genuinely transactional pricing — pay-as-you-go with a 30-day refundable trial, plus 23+ native channel integrations and FBA-prep specialty.
eFulfillment Service
Per-order billing since 2001 with no setup fees, monthly minimums, or long-term contracts — the lineup's only true SMB-friendly transactional 3PL.
eFulfillment Service has been billing per-order since 2001 from a single 200,000 sqft facility in Traverse City, Michigan. Founder John Lindberg's family still runs it. The pitch sets it apart from every software-first 3PL in this lineup: no setup fees, no monthly minimums, no long-term contracts, and a 30-day refundable trial. Multichannel Merchant has named eFS a Top 3PL every year the list has run. Native integrations span Shopify, Amazon, eBay, Etsy, Walmart, TikTok Shop, Target+, plus 16 more — the deepest channel coverage for an SMB-focused 3PL. Specialties include FBA-prep, subscription boxes, books and media, kitting, and crowdfunding fulfillment. Not a fit for brands needing 2-day national coverage (the single-warehouse footprint cannot deliver it), two-way cart sync, or volume past roughly 1,000 orders per month. For SMB DTC and marketplace sellers under that threshold who want per-order billing and dedicated account support without committing to a 3PL relationship, eFS is the lineup's only true SMB pick.
- Best for
- SMB DTC and marketplace sellers under roughly 1,000 orders per month who want per-order billing and dedicated account support.
- Operational edge
- Genuinely transactional pricing — pay-as-you-go with a 30-day refundable trial, plus 23+ native channel integrations and FBA-prep specialty.
Flexport
Combines the former Deliverr fast-shipping network with Flexport's freight-forwarding platform — one vendor from ocean container to consumer doorstep.
- Best for
- Mid-market Shopify brands shipping 2,000+ orders per month that import internationally.
- Edge
- End-to-end import + fulfillment under a single vendor, with Shop Promise badge support on Shopify.
Flexport
Combines the former Deliverr fast-shipping network with Flexport's freight-forwarding platform — one vendor from ocean container to consumer doorstep.
Flexport eCommerce Fulfillment is what is left of Deliverr after Shopify's 2022 acquisition and Flexport's 2023 takeover. Five US warehouses across California, Texas, Illinois, Georgia, and New Jersey now operate under the Flexport brand, paired with the company's freight-forwarding platform. The pitch is end-to-end: ocean container, customs, deconsolidation, fulfillment, doorstep — one vendor and one billing relationship. Shop Promise badge support on Shopify is a meaningful conversion lift for Shopify-first brands. Pricing reset January 1, 2026 to a $5,000 per month minimum (up from $500/month in mid-2025), which pushes the value prop firmly into mid-market territory. Not a fit for SMB merchants under 1,500 orders/month, brands needing white-glove account management, or US-only DTC with no import volume. For brands importing significant inventory and wanting freight and fulfillment under one roof, Flexport is the lineup's only true integrated answer.
- Best for
- Mid-market Shopify brands shipping 2,000+ orders per month that import internationally.
- Operational edge
- End-to-end import + fulfillment under a single vendor, with Shop Promise badge support on Shopify.
Fulfyld
Published per-order rate card starting at $7.56 for 4–12oz with 24/7 dedicated human account managers — flat budget predictability without a platform-fee layer.
- Best for
- Mid-market DTC, subscription box, and crowdfunding brands shipping ~500–5,000 orders per month who value flat-rate pricing and a named human contact.
- Edge
- Public flat-rate per-order pricing paired with 24/7 dedicated human account managers reachable by phone or text — no platform fees, no consolidators, no setup costs.
Fulfyld
Published per-order rate card starting at $7.56 for 4–12oz with 24/7 dedicated human account managers — flat budget predictability without a platform-fee layer.
Fulfyld is a 2016-founded, Huntsville-Alabama-based 3PL operating from a single Southeast US facility (511 6th St, Madison AL) and built around two specific claims: flat-rate per-order pricing with a published rate card, and 24/7 dedicated human account managers reachable by phone or text. The pricing page anchors the first at $7.56+ for the 4–12oz standard tier (label, packaging, 5 free picks included), $3.50 + $0.50 returns, and tiered storage from $1.25–$2.50/mo per small bin up to $16–$32/mo per pallet. Native integrations run 23+ platforms including Shopify, Shopify Plus, Amazon Seller Central, TikTok, BackerKit, Cratejoy, NetSuite, and Salesforce. For FBA-alternative evaluation, Fulfyld offers dedicated FBA prep as a service plus native Seller Central integration. Not a fit for West Coast or Pacific Northwest buyer concentration — the single Huntsville facility means 2-day national shipping relies on expedited carriers rather than a multi-warehouse network. Also not a fit for deep cold-chain operations or enterprise scale past roughly 50,000 orders per month. For mid-market DTC, subscription box, and Kickstarter brands inside the right geographic window who want flat-rate per-order pricing and a named human contact, Fulfyld is the lineup's strongest pick on those two specific axes.
- Best for
- Mid-market DTC, subscription box, and crowdfunding brands shipping ~500–5,000 orders per month who value flat-rate pricing and a named human contact.
- Operational edge
- Public flat-rate per-order pricing paired with 24/7 dedicated human account managers reachable by phone or text — no platform fees, no consolidators, no setup costs.
Why operators start looking beyond Amazon FBA
This page is for ecommerce operators evaluating where to send some or all of their FBA volume. It is not for sellers with under 5 SKUs at high Prime velocity and tight turn rates — those sellers usually still beat 3PL economics with FBA. For everyone else, four replacement models are worth understanding before naming a vendor: a full-replacement 3PL (the focus of this page), a hybrid setup that keeps FBA for fast-moving SKUs and routes the rest to a 3PL, a platform shift to Walmart Fulfillment Services or Shopify-native, and Amazon's own alternatives — Multi-Channel Fulfillment, Seller Fulfilled Prime, and Fulfilled by Merchant. The right answer depends on what you sell, how heavy it is, how many channels you are on, and whether you are leaving FBA entirely or de-risking. The nine 3PLs below — ordered by which seller profile they fit best — cover the realistic options most brands choose between.
- Best for
- Amazon-first sellers who need Prime speed and marketplace badge advantages.
- Usually not ideal for
- Brand-building DTC operators who need custom packaging or handling control.
- Minimum monthly orders
- No minimum
Why sellers are leaving FBA in 2026
Fee structure is no longer predictable
Storage utilization surcharges now run $1.58 per cubic foot for inventory carried 44–52 weeks, climbing to $1.88 per cubic foot once stock crosses 52 weeks. During Q4 peak — Amazon's October 15 to January 14 window — standard storage jumps from $0.78 to $2.40 per cubic foot, oversize from $0.56 to $1.40. Per-unit holiday fulfillment surcharges add another $0.20 to $1.00 on top of the regular FBA fee. A seller modeling Q4 economics on Q1 fees is off by roughly 200 percent on storage alone.
Capacity limits restrict inbound shipments
Amazon now requires an Inventory Performance Index score of at least 550 — up from 500 a year ago — to avoid storage limits. Sellers below the threshold get hit with Storage Limit Alerts and can no longer create new inbound shipments at will. Capacity calculations dropped from six months to five months of projected sales in May 2025, and ASIN-level 90-day supply caps are back: an individual product can be capped even when overall account capacity looks healthy. The structural effect is a ceiling on how much inventory FBA accepts, regardless of turn rate.
Prep removal makes 3PLs structurally cheaper
Amazon discontinued FBA prep and labeling services in the US on January 1, 2026. Sellers who relied on Amazon to bag, label, or polybag every unit now either bring prep in-house, hire an FBA prep service as a separate vendor, or move to a 3PL that includes prep in the fulfillment fee. The third option compresses two line items into one. For brands with significant prep volume — supplements, apparel, multipacks — the math moved noticeably in favor of full-service 3PLs the day the change took effect.
Brand control is limited inside FBA
Amazon ships in Amazon-branded packaging. Custom inserts, custom packaging, branded packing slips, and post-purchase upsells are not options. Inventory commingling — where Amazon pools your units with other sellers' units of the same ASIN — exposes brands to counterfeit risk that traces back to your product on the customer end. Brands building a defensible DTC moat hit a ceiling inside FBA that 3PLs do not impose.
FBA-only is the wrong topology for multichannel growth
Shopify direct, TikTok Shop, Walmart, eBay, and wholesale orders all need fulfillment. Routing them through Amazon's Multi-Channel Fulfillment is possible but expensive, and inherits the same capacity exposure as FBA itself. A 3PL handles every channel from one inventory pool with one set of fees. As DTC and TikTok Shop grow as a share of revenue, the FBA-only operator is fighting a structural mismatch.
Alternative models that aren't 3PLs
Not every alternative to FBA is a 3PL. Four other models are worth knowing before deciding.
Walmart Fulfillment Services (WFS)
Walmart Fulfillment Services charges no monthly fee and requires no paid subscription from the buyer to qualify for two-day delivery. Fees run consistently 6 to 8 percentage points lower than equivalent FBA fees. The catch: WFS only fulfills Walmart.com orders. It is a platform-replacement strategy, not a 3PL — useful for brands where Walmart is already 20% or more of revenue, or where the brand wants to shift center of gravity away from Amazon. Seller approval is selective; new accounts face stricter vetting than FBA's onboarding.
Multi-Channel Fulfillment (MCF)
Amazon's Multi-Channel Fulfillment uses FBA inventory to fulfill non-Amazon orders. On paper it looks like a 3PL — one warehouse network, multiple channels — but every unit shipped through MCF was first counted against your IPI score and capacity allocation. Storage, aged-inventory, and capacity penalties apply identically to MCF and FBA orders. MCF works best as a short-term bridge while transitioning to a 3PL, not as a destination.
Seller Fulfilled Prime (SFP)
Seller Fulfilled Prime lets a brand keep the Prime badge while shipping from its own (or a 3PL's) warehouse. The SLA gate is demanding: 99% on-time shipping, two-day delivery to most US zips, weekend pickup capability, and direct Amazon Buy Shipping integration. Most brands need a Prime-certified 3PL to qualify. In this lineup, Red Stag and ShipMonk explicitly support SFP. ShipBob does not — it offers FBA prep services instead. SFP is the right answer for brands with Prime-velocity SKUs that cannot survive an unbadged listing.
Fulfilled by Merchant (FBM) plus a 3PL
Fulfilled by Merchant is the hybrid most brands land on: a 3PL handles fulfillment for Amazon FBM listings alongside Shopify and other DTC channels. It produces the lowest Amazon-side fee structure of any option since FBA fees disappear entirely, but loses the Prime badge unless the seller also qualifies for SFP. Pairs well with a 3PL that has strong Amazon integration (most in the lineup below qualify) and a brand willing to trade some conversion rate for lower fulfillment cost and more control.
Co-warehousing (Saltbox and similar)
Co-warehousing platforms rent flexible suite space alongside on-demand labor and shipping discounts on month-to-month terms. They sit between full self-fulfillment and a 3PL — closer to a managed warehouse than a fulfillment vendor. Best for very early-stage or seasonal brands wanting to control fulfillment quality without signing a 3PL contract. Most operators outgrow this model once daily order volume crosses 100.
Alternative selection questions
How much does it cost to switch from Amazon FBA to a 3PL?
Most brands see 20 to 40 percent lower total fulfillment cost after switching to a quality 3PL, but the comparison only holds when storage, long-term storage surcharges, Q4 peak surcharges, removal fees, and (since January 2026) prep service costs are all included on the FBA side. For high-Prime-velocity small-and-light SKUs under 1 lb, FBA can still win on raw per-unit math. Get quotes from two or three 3PLs and model six months of seasonality, not one month of flat sales.
Can I use Amazon FBA and a 3PL at the same time?
Yes. Hybrid setups are the most common transition pattern. Brands typically keep their highest-velocity Amazon SKUs at FBA for Prime speed, route slower-moving inventory and DTC orders to a 3PL, and adjust the split over the first year based on margin per channel.
What is the cheapest alternative to Amazon FBA?
On per-unit fees, Walmart Fulfillment Services typically runs 6 to 8 percentage points lower than FBA — but only fulfills Walmart.com orders. For multichannel cheap-ness, Fulfilled by Merchant with a true SMB 3PL like eFulfillment Service (the only no-monthly-minimums option in this lineup) usually produces the lowest total cost, with the tradeoff of losing the Prime badge.
What is the difference between Amazon MCF and a 3PL?
Multi-Channel Fulfillment routes non-Amazon orders through FBA inventory. It uses FBA fees, FBA capacity allocation, and the FBA IPI score. A 3PL maintains separate inventory in its own warehouses, charges its own fees, and is not subject to Amazon's storage limits or aged-inventory penalties. MCF is a feature of FBA, not a replacement for it.
Do I lose my Prime badge if I leave FBA?
Not necessarily. Seller Fulfilled Prime keeps the Prime badge while you ship from a 3PL's warehouse, but you have to qualify under Amazon's SLA — 99% on-time shipping, two-day delivery coverage, and Buy Shipping integration. Red Stag and ShipMonk in this lineup are SFP-capable. ShipBob currently is not.
How long does it take to migrate inventory from FBA to a 3PL?
Four to eight weeks is typical. The path: submit a removal order in Seller Central, wait for Amazon to ship inventory back, transit to the new 3PL, receive and inspect, integrate channel feeds, run parallel for a week to catch issues, and cut over. Each step has variance — Amazon removal alone can take 14 to 30 days during peak season.
Is Walmart Fulfillment Services a real alternative to FBA?
Yes, but only for Walmart-channel volume. WFS is a platform-shift, not a multichannel solution — it cannot fulfill Shopify, Amazon, or eBay orders. Useful for brands where Walmart is already a meaningful share of revenue (often 20% or more), or where the brand wants to grow the Walmart channel deliberately.
Which 3PL in this lineup is best for Amazon prep specifically?
Since Amazon ended FBA prep services on January 1, 2026, every 3PL in this lineup offers some level of FBA prep, but quality and price vary. ShipBob and eFulfillment Service lean into Amazon-prep capability as a selling point — eFS lists FBA-prep as a named specialty. Red Stag's prep is included for SFP customers. For brands prep-heavy enough that this is the deciding factor, get a sample prep quote from two or three options before committing.
Tell us what your fulfillment operation needs.
Share your order volume, catalog profile, platform stack, and shipping needs. We will review the submission and respond with a recommended next step.